My Mascot
Brome Squirrel Buster vs Yankee Whipper
Comparison Test #1 — Seed leakage from ports. Check out the photo showing each feeder after 24 hours hanging in the exact same spot with the same weather conditions. The Brome seems to have ports that leak more seed. I had this suspicion just eyeing the feeder after filling it up the first time with seed.
The photo shows the 24-hour test results. I measured the seed loss in cups as well, and the Brome lost an additional cup over the 24 hour period.
Two Great Feeders: Head-to-Head Tests
As you know from prior posts, my “Gold Standard” all-around champion feeder is the Droll Yankees Yankee Whipper.
However, the #1 selling feeder on Duncraft’s site is the Brome Squirrel-Buster Plus, made by the great nation of Kanuckistan, just north of my home state. It costs about $100 retail, but on Amazon it’s about $75.
So I bought the latest model (Plus) and the cardinal ring (which allows them to perch easily).
Assembly was simple, and I attached the cardinal ring right away.
The patented squirrel-proofing feature of this feeder is the The Squirrel Buster’s adjustable, weight-sensitive, metal skirt that drops down with the weight of a squirrel or large bird to block the six ports.
It comes out of the box calibrated to keep out squirrels, but you can change the calibration after you see how it’s working in your yard. Might take a few fine-tunings to get it exactly right to keep out grackles or whatever pesky birds you’re trying to thward. Here’s a photo of the part you adjust:
And the instructions show you how to calibrate.
So here it is, hung off my deck, with a new customer.
Brome Peanut Plus Feeder – 1st Week
The Brome Peanut + Feeder arrived and I hung it out promptly. Within 10 minutes I had a chickadee at it. Chickadees are always first due to their curiousity and fearlessness.
Next in boldness was the white-breasted nuthatch, who likes to hang upside down to eat:
Then came the downy woodpeckers:
Review: Brome Peanut Plus Feeder
The feeder came and I immediately filled it with peanuts (it holds 3 cups). I glanced at the directions to make sure that the factory setting on the calibration would keep the squirrels from accessing the feeder ports — yup! All set to hang.
Here are some close-up photos of how it works. The upper part of the mesh cylinder gets weighted down and covers the feeder ports of anything heavier than a bird clings to it.
Looks like a smart design that will work well, but let’s hang it up and see. Full review to come after some time observing how it handles birds and varmints.
Custom Baffle for Small Tube Feeder
I bought the perfect baffle for my small Audubon-brand tube feeder. It has a slot in the top made just for these types of hangers, so the baffle doesn’t rattle around in the wind, or hang there at a jaunty slant. This keeps the seed dry, which is important with sunflower chips, so they don’t rot.
New Peanut Feeder – I just ordered!
Review coming soon on this squirrel-proof (and big-bird-proof) feeder. It has a mesh sleeve that lowers down to block the feeding ports if something too heavy lands on it. So you can calibrate it, just like the Brome tube feeders. I’m curious to see if I can keep the blue jays off, but still allow the larger woodpeckers.
Birds Choice Thistle Feeder – One Year Later
One-year follow up on the yellow feeder I reviewed. OK, so I’m not as impressed as I was at first.  This feeder leaks way too much seed — the mesh is not woven tightly enough.  Too bad, because it has so much going for it otherwise. I have gone back and modified my review to lower the rating a little.
So I have switched over to my old stand-by, the Droll Yankees feeder.
And since this one is so miserly on seed (with its tiny little ports where birds peck the seeds out), I splurged on some extra-nice finch feed.
Yankee Whipper – Easy Cleaning
Another reason I think this is the best feeder around: easy to clean. To dismantle it for dishwasher cleaning, just undo four screws. Even a monkey (with the right tool) could do it.
Then you have the tube separated from the unit with the perches. I put the big tube on the lower rack of dishwasher and the blue part on the upper rack.  I also throw the lid on the top rack. For sanitation reasons, wash your feeder BY ITSELF, since it may have bird poop on it, and hence bacteria.

Top Rack



































































































































